The feature article on last Sunday’s Vima Science discussing University Rankings presented a research paper authored by Michael Taylor, Varvara Trachana, Stelios Gialis and myself. The Vima Science article uses data and arguments presented in our paper to criticise current University indices that are constructed from a list of arbitrary indicators combined using subjective weightings. The article specifically focuses on how these rankings fail to capture the high productivity of Greek scientists and University students as measured through citation data, and discusses Michael’s suggestions on what criteria should students and parents use in order to select a suitable University.
You can read the full article online here: http://www.tovima.gr/science/article/?aid=610392
or download the pdf version.
Originally published at: http://www.int-res.com/abstracts/esep/v13/n2/pp10/
Our article exposing the weaknesses of the current system of University rankings was recently published in the Journal of Ethics in Science and Environmental Politics. Bellow the article’s abstract:
Global university rankings are a powerful force shaping higher education policy worldwide. Several different ranking systems exist, but they all suffer from the same mathematical shortcoming – their ranking index is constructed from a list of arbitrary indicators combined using subjective weightings. Yet, different ranking systems consistently point to a cohort of mostly US and UK privately-funded universities as being the ‘best’. Moreover, the status of these nations as leaders in global higher education is reinforced each year with the exclusion of world-class universities from other countries from the top 200. Continue reading “Our article on University Rankings published in the Journal of Ethics in Science and Environmental Politics”